Ken Gergen on Social Constructionism

Ken Gergen, professor at Swarthmore College and president of the Taos Institute, provides a very nice introduction to social constructionism. Not a philosophy or a belief system, social constructionism, for Gergen, is more a way of talking about or writing about our experience with the world. This experience is a product of language and of the stories that define our interaction with the world and these stories are a product of our relationships. Rather than threatening scientific ways of thinking, as is the mistaken belief in many circles, social constructionism values scientific methods, and indeed other forms of pragmatism for that matter, but simply declines to give science particular authority over other alternatives. Very thought provoking.

Posted in Cooperation, Social Constructionism | Leave a comment

The Checklist Manifesto

Atul Gawande begins his latest book, The Checklist Manifesto, by bringing to our attention an epistemological crisis of sorts. In his view, most of our history has been marred by errors of ignorance, which came about because we just didn’t possess the knowledge to solve many problems. Today, on the other hand, we are more likely to commit errors of ineptitude. Ineptitude seems a bit harsh here, and I prefer to think of them as errors resulting from cognitive limitations, but the point is that we now know so much, we can’t seem to wield this knowledge effectively to solve modern problems. We face a serious knowledge management problem.

Gawande’s solution for this crisis is the humble…checklist. He offers a number of convincing stories, from such domains as aviation and surgery, where checklists have saved lives and saved money – and makes the much bolder claim that checklists might have universal applicability, a claim that might want to sew his case up a little neater than might be possible. The book, as well as it’s companion website, offers a number of example checklists and even a checklist checklist, which provides a summary of checklist design guidelines.

However general Gawande’s thesis may be, anyone who has ever had any significant interaction with our healthcare system will recognize the crisis of expertise that is at the heart of his manifesto. It is a serious problem, worthy of serious attention. And Gawande has made a smart contribution to the discourse, which, at the same time, happens to be entertaining.

Posted in Books, Decision-Making, Design | Leave a comment

Thinking With Your Eyes

Lothar Krempel, of the Max Planck Institute for the Study of Societies in Cologne, is leading a highly multi-disciplinary effort to create a scientific method of visualization of network data. While statistical methods, like multidimensional scaling, factor analysis, and correspondence analysis, have long been in use to make sense of relationship based data, Krempel’s beautiful graphics make these relationships palpable, even intuitive, and this is due to the evolved capacity of our eyes to process many different pieces of complex information concurrently. “These are preattentive processes that happen really fast and automatically,” stresses Krempel. In essence, the eyes are carrying part of the load before they hand a task with reduced complexity over to the brain. Sure, part of this cognitive preprocessing is happening outside of our heads entirely…in computers and on paper. But if visualizations are carefully designed, cognizant of human neurological capabilities and limitations, then designers can facilitate an advantageous process of “thinking with our eyes.” Read more about Krempel’s work here.

Posted in Augmented Cognition, Complex Systems, Design, Visualization | Leave a comment

Game Theory on Networks: An In Silico Laboratory

Dan Katz, from Michigan Political Science, the Center for the Study of Complex Systems, and Computational Legal Studies, is including a simulation platform that I wrote in NetLogo as part of the curriculum at the ICPSR (Inter-University Consortium for Political and Social Research) Summer Program in Quantitative Methods.

The simulation is designed to conduct simple game theoretic experiments on networks and provides wide capabilities to vary game structure and network architecture parameters.  What features of networks promote cooperative behavior under various game theoretic conditions?

You can experiment with your own simulations on-line here.  The NetLogo source code can be downloaded here.  This off-line instantiation requires NetLogo 3.1.5, but should be easily updated for the latest NetLogo versions.  A very basic single-sheet tutorial is available here.  And finally, a piece of research conducted using the tool can be found here.

Posted in Agent-Based Models, Complex Systems, Computation, Cooperation, Evolution, Game Theory, Prisoner's Dilemma, Programming, Social Networks | Leave a comment

Identity Economics

George Akerlof and Rachel Kranton have a new book that proposes to add identity and norms to the economic representation of tastes.  Current economic thinking views tastes as a characteristic of the individual, but they suggest that identity derives from the social setting.  “The incorporation of identity and norms then yields a theory of decision making where social context matters.”  Most significantly for the context of my current work, Akerlof and Kranton note that we can observe these “categories, norms and ideals” in narrative – in how individuals talk about their lives.

Posted in Books, Identity, Narrative | Leave a comment

Understanding Resistance to Apology, Forgiveness, and Reconciliation

My work with Doug Yarn on inter-group conflict, apology, and forgiveness was published in Duke’s Law and Contemporary Problems. The article, along with the other contributions to the volume as pdfs, is available here.

Posted in Apology, Forgiveness, Inter-Group Conflict | Leave a comment

Autonomous Agents for Heuristic Design

My work related to the use of autonomous agents for heuristic design was published in the new book on negotiation pedagogy edited by Chris Honeyman, James Coben & Giuseppe De Palo and available from DRI Press. This compilation resulted from an amazing meeting in Rome last year supported by the JAMS Foundation and attended by more than 50 of the leading scholars on negotiation and conflict resolution. All of the contributions are available as pdfs here.

Posted in Autonomous Agents, Books, Heuristics, Negotiation | Leave a comment

Narrative Networks, Social Identity and Complexity in Collective Action

I recently gave a NSF sponsored talk at Duke Computer Science in conjunction with the HarambeeNet SocialNets in Education Project.  I raised the question regarding the evolution of cooperative behavior beyond a certain level of social complexity and suggested that successful collective action might depend on identity-promoting institutional design, which itself would depend on coherent narrative.  In essence, our tendency for cooperative behavior could have co-evolved with our penchant for storytelling.  And storytelling provides the relative speed of cultural evolution and an efficient means of reducing behavioral space in response to the frame problem described in an earlier post.  The full slide deck is available here.

Posted in Collaboration, Collective Intelligence, Complex Systems, Cooperation, Evolution, Identity, Narrative, Public Good, Social Networks | Leave a comment

Evolution = Informed Social Change

An evolutionary understanding of human behavior does not lead inevitably to genetic determinism.  On the contrary.  An evolutionary view allows for informed social change.  Getting our arms around environmental and biological conditions that produce desired outcomes makes it more likely that we can design institutions to bring them about.

Posted in Evolution, Institutional Design | Leave a comment

The Surprising Science of Motivation

According to vice-presidential (under Gore) speechwriter turned career analyst and author, Daniel Pink, the emerging champion of right brain vocation, there is a dramatic mismatch between the science of motivation and what business actually does. Whereas typical financial incentives work in contexts where the work is strictly mechanical, contexts that require even a modicum of creativity require incentives built around autonomy, personal growth, and purpose. Pink points to numerous cross-cultural studies that consistently support these conclusions. Check out Pink’s Oxford TED talk on the science of motivation here.

Daniel H. Pink, Drive: The Surprising Truth About What Motivates Us (Riverhead, 2009).

Posted in Books, Creativity, Decision-Making, Innovation | Leave a comment